Not trying to but in, but Laurel has been pretty much hit and miss for me all fall/winter. I've caught alot more trout than SM on the fly this winter as have alot of people i've talked to. I talked with a friend of mine who fishes pretty seriously and fishes Cumberland regularly this past weekend, and he said Cumberland has slowed down some in the past couple of weeks but is still pretty decent. If the drive was equal all things considered i'd say go to Cumberland, although Laurel can produce some big smallies like the one Milkshake's partner boated the other day.